Case study:Ullswater Catchment Restoration: Difference between revisions
No edit summary |
No edit summary |
||
| (9 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
{{Case study status}} | {{Case study status | ||
|Approval status=Approved | |||
}} | |||
{{Location | {{Location | ||
|Location=54.5761793, -2.8860129 | |Location=54.5761793, -2.8860129 | ||
| Line 5: | Line 7: | ||
{{Project overview | {{Project overview | ||
|Status=Complete | |Status=Complete | ||
|Themes=Flood risk management, | |Themes=Economic aspects, Environmental flows and water resources, Flood risk management, Hydromorphology, Land use management - agriculture, Monitoring, Peat, Social benefits, Water quality | ||
|Country=England | |Country=England | ||
|Main contact forename= | |Main contact forename=Alice | ||
|Main contact surname=James | |Main contact surname=James | ||
|Main contact id=AliceJames | |Main contact id=AliceJames | ||
| Line 13: | Line 15: | ||
|Contact organisation url=www.nationaltrust.org.uk/ | |Contact organisation url=www.nationaltrust.org.uk/ | ||
|Multi-site=Yes | |Multi-site=Yes | ||
|Project picture=Ullswater CIC riparian restoration befor & after.png | |||
|Picture description=Ullswater CIC riparian restoration before & after | |||
|Project summary=Ullswater - Winner of 'catchment-scale award - RiverPrize 2024 | |||
Ullswater is one of the most iconic destinations in the Lake District, attracting millions of visitors every year and home to thriving rural communities. However, decades of agricultural intensification and land use change have resulted in highly modified river and declining biodiversity. The Ullswater catchment restoration project seeks to reverse this decline in habitat and natural processes through working with landowners and local communities to foster change at a catchment scale. | |||
The project area includes the headwaters systems, tributaries, rivers, and catchment land draining into Ullswater. These systems have been historically modified to improve the valley bottom areas for farming, with straightening, deepening, embanking, revetments, and width rationalisation a common sight. Hidden alterations to the functioning of the system are also present with underdrainage significantly impacting on the natural hydrology. The consequence of such high levels of modification combined with a changing climate has increased the flood risk to local communities. This is coupled with frequent seasonal drying of main river systems during periods of reduced rainfall. Valley floor modification is significant, and the combined effect of all changes has been to severely degrade the wet environment with consequent losses of biodiversity. | |||
In response the Ullswater catchment Partnership has been working to deliver management initiatives and physical interventions for almost 10years. The partners have delivered 282 projects, including over 13km of river restoration, 46ha of water storage, 12km of hedgerow creation, 497ha of wood pasture restoration and 249ha of peat and wetland restoration. A key large-scale achievement has been the river and valley bottom naturalisation work which stretches from the bottom of Kirkstone Pass to Ullswater and includes large areas of the Brothers Water SSSI and the River Eden and tributaries SSSI. | |||
Numerous farm scale initiatives have been carried out across the catchment with the partnership carrying out restoration across a total area of 843ha. The interventions across the catchment include: | |||
*River restoration through de-culverting, embankment removal, small barrier removal, stage 0 interventions, and re-meandering over 13.7km | |||
*Pond creation and offline water storage totalling 46ha. | |||
*Hedgerow creation and restoration and riparian corridor restoration over 16km | |||
*Wood pasture creation and restoration across 497ha | |||
*Peat and wetland restoration over 249ha | |||
|Monitoring surveys and results=The project outputs are monitored through several approaches including repeat freshwater and terrestrial ecological surveying, soil nutrient, organic matter and carbon sequestration analysis, sediment storage analysis, hydrological monitoring of large interventions, fish surveying and redd counting and citizen science monitoring initiatives. | |||
Work in the Ullswater catchment has comprised numerous small-scale farm-based interventions through to larger strategic works to naturalise the bigger watercourse and floodplain areas. To date 282 projects have been completed with a combined area of 843ha. | |||
249ha of upland peat restoration has included 16,200 peat bunds, 12,000m of peat hag re-profiling and 21ha of sphagnum inoculation. Wood pasture restoration and creation covers 497ha and combined with 16km of hedgerow creation over 150,000 trees have been planted. Pond and wetland creation has resulted in 46ha of standing water habitat. River restoration has been carried out over 13.7km and includes small barrier removals, de-culverting, fish passes, stage 0 restoration, constrained restoration, and re-meandering. | |||
Monitoring of the wider catchment works shows that where hedgerows and wood pasture have been created there has been a very swift response in earthworm numbers compared to adjacent sampling sites. Whilst there is no evidence of changes in nutrients or carbon storage, this would not be expected immediately. However, the partnership is committed to re-testing these sites on a 5-yearly basis. There is clear evidence through photographs and surveying of the new hedgerows and riparian restoration areas having a significant increase in flora with species such as Vetch, Red Campion, Dog Violet, and Greater Stitchwort’s now common. Where peat restoration has been carried out there is now a healthy fauna of Sphagnum Spp., Bog Asphodel, Cotton Grass, and Sundews present representing a healthy hydrology. | |||
Three large river restoration projects have been carried out in the valley bottom. These projects have been heavily monitored for hydrology, sediment transport, fish, macrophyte and terrestrial ecology. The naturalisation aimed to restore form and process, rejuvenating a range of river types and associated valley bottom systems. The project completed at Hartsop Hall, over 2.1km, saw the wetted channel area increase from 1850m2 to 23,300m2. At Goldrill Beck the project, over 1.6km, saw the wetted channel area increase by 21,590m2. Hydrological data shows that the impact on flood flows has been a mean event lag time increase of 41.3 minutes, with some events having an event lag time increase of 90 minutes. Coarse sediment is also now being stored across the valley bottom with repeat survey showing that more than 2000 m3 of sediment has been stored on one site. The original species-poor assemblage of rush pasture and semi-improved grassland has been disturbed and the vegetation has begun to diversify. The newly formed gravel bars are hosting the greatest diversity of plants, as species that are suited to disturbance and early colonisation are taking advantage. Species such as Corn Spurrey, Bottle Sedge, Fox Glove, and Devils Bit Scabious are increasing in prevalence across the sites, with the partnership now pursuing an expansion of Devils Bit Scabious habitat across the valley prior to a Marsh Fritillary Butterfly re-introduction. Several bird and butterfly species have been recorded on the river restoration sites for the first time, including Jack Snipe, Great White Egret and Small Pearl Bordered Fritillary Butterfly. | |||
|Lessons learn=The biggest success has been the meaningful partnership developed with all landowners and farmers who have worked with us over the past 10 years. A relationship of trust and respect has been built through collaboration, ensuring they are treated as a true partner, can input into design, oversee construction, and take ownership of the results. The momentum of project delivery is increasing, and this can be attributed to the commitment to building and maintaining these relationships. | |||
Funding for projects such as this can be incredibly hard to come by and the partnerships commitment to showcasing our work and communicating passionately about our objectives has resulted in significant income through private donations and crowd funders. A community far wider than Ullswater feel invested in our work. | |||
The partnership has also worked hard to improve local skills and education opportunities. Through the Riverlands project we have hosted 3 apprentices over the last 6 years, galvanising a new generation of river champions. We have worked with local contractors for all projects, providing a learning space for local construction companies to diversify into natural flood management and habitat works. The volume of work has supported numerous small contractors who are now as much a partner to the project as anyone. They have developed a deep understanding of how important it is to protect this landscape and the methods they can use to enhance it. | |||
}} | }} | ||
{{Image gallery}} | {{Image gallery}} | ||
| Line 38: | Line 77: | ||
|File name=Ust to Dst Hartsop Edited reduced.jpg | |File name=Ust to Dst Hartsop Edited reduced.jpg | ||
|Caption=Riverlands Kirkstone Beck River Restoration completed | |Caption=Riverlands Kirkstone Beck River Restoration completed | ||
}} | |||
{{Case study image | |||
|File name=https://youtu.be/kUaK5kDIzWg | |||
|Caption=Video of the programme | |||
}} | }} | ||
{{Image gallery end}} | {{Image gallery end}} | ||
| Line 58: | Line 101: | ||
{{Monitoring documents end}} | {{Monitoring documents end}} | ||
{{Additional Documents}} | {{Additional Documents}} | ||
{{Case study documents | |||
|File name=https://youtu.be/kUaK5kDIzWg | |||
|Description=RiverPrize video | |||
}} | |||
{{Additional Documents end}} | {{Additional Documents end}} | ||
{{Additional links and references header}} | {{Additional links and references header}} | ||
| Line 63: | Line 110: | ||
{{Supplementary Information}} | {{Supplementary Information}} | ||
{{Toggle content end}} | {{Toggle content end}} | ||
{{Case study status | |||
|Approval status=Approved | |||
}} | |||
{{Location | |||
|Location=54.5761793, -2.8860129 | |||
}} | |||
Latest revision as of 14:47, 10 December 2024
Project overview
| Status | Complete |
|---|---|
| Project web site | |
| Themes | Economic aspects, Environmental flows and water resources, Flood risk management, Hydromorphology, Land use management - agriculture, Monitoring, Peat, Social benefits, Water quality |
| Country | England |
| Main contact forename | Alice |
| Main contact surname | James |
| Main contact user ID | User:AliceJames |
| Contact organisation | The National Trust for Places of Historic Interest or Natural Beauty |
| Contact organisation web site | http://www.nationaltrust.org.uk/ |
| Partner organisations | |
| This is a parent project encompassing the following projects |
Goldrill Beck River Restoration, Kirkstone Beck River Restoration, Thackthwaite catchment restoration |
Project summary
Ullswater - Winner of 'catchment-scale award - RiverPrize 2024
Ullswater is one of the most iconic destinations in the Lake District, attracting millions of visitors every year and home to thriving rural communities. However, decades of agricultural intensification and land use change have resulted in highly modified river and declining biodiversity. The Ullswater catchment restoration project seeks to reverse this decline in habitat and natural processes through working with landowners and local communities to foster change at a catchment scale.
The project area includes the headwaters systems, tributaries, rivers, and catchment land draining into Ullswater. These systems have been historically modified to improve the valley bottom areas for farming, with straightening, deepening, embanking, revetments, and width rationalisation a common sight. Hidden alterations to the functioning of the system are also present with underdrainage significantly impacting on the natural hydrology. The consequence of such high levels of modification combined with a changing climate has increased the flood risk to local communities. This is coupled with frequent seasonal drying of main river systems during periods of reduced rainfall. Valley floor modification is significant, and the combined effect of all changes has been to severely degrade the wet environment with consequent losses of biodiversity.
In response the Ullswater catchment Partnership has been working to deliver management initiatives and physical interventions for almost 10years. The partners have delivered 282 projects, including over 13km of river restoration, 46ha of water storage, 12km of hedgerow creation, 497ha of wood pasture restoration and 249ha of peat and wetland restoration. A key large-scale achievement has been the river and valley bottom naturalisation work which stretches from the bottom of Kirkstone Pass to Ullswater and includes large areas of the Brothers Water SSSI and the River Eden and tributaries SSSI.
Numerous farm scale initiatives have been carried out across the catchment with the partnership carrying out restoration across a total area of 843ha. The interventions across the catchment include:
- River restoration through de-culverting, embankment removal, small barrier removal, stage 0 interventions, and re-meandering over 13.7km
- Pond creation and offline water storage totalling 46ha.
- Hedgerow creation and restoration and riparian corridor restoration over 16km
- Wood pasture creation and restoration across 497ha
- Peat and wetland restoration over 249ha
Monitoring surveys and results
The project outputs are monitored through several approaches including repeat freshwater and terrestrial ecological surveying, soil nutrient, organic matter and carbon sequestration analysis, sediment storage analysis, hydrological monitoring of large interventions, fish surveying and redd counting and citizen science monitoring initiatives.
Work in the Ullswater catchment has comprised numerous small-scale farm-based interventions through to larger strategic works to naturalise the bigger watercourse and floodplain areas. To date 282 projects have been completed with a combined area of 843ha.
249ha of upland peat restoration has included 16,200 peat bunds, 12,000m of peat hag re-profiling and 21ha of sphagnum inoculation. Wood pasture restoration and creation covers 497ha and combined with 16km of hedgerow creation over 150,000 trees have been planted. Pond and wetland creation has resulted in 46ha of standing water habitat. River restoration has been carried out over 13.7km and includes small barrier removals, de-culverting, fish passes, stage 0 restoration, constrained restoration, and re-meandering.
Monitoring of the wider catchment works shows that where hedgerows and wood pasture have been created there has been a very swift response in earthworm numbers compared to adjacent sampling sites. Whilst there is no evidence of changes in nutrients or carbon storage, this would not be expected immediately. However, the partnership is committed to re-testing these sites on a 5-yearly basis. There is clear evidence through photographs and surveying of the new hedgerows and riparian restoration areas having a significant increase in flora with species such as Vetch, Red Campion, Dog Violet, and Greater Stitchwort’s now common. Where peat restoration has been carried out there is now a healthy fauna of Sphagnum Spp., Bog Asphodel, Cotton Grass, and Sundews present representing a healthy hydrology.
Three large river restoration projects have been carried out in the valley bottom. These projects have been heavily monitored for hydrology, sediment transport, fish, macrophyte and terrestrial ecology. The naturalisation aimed to restore form and process, rejuvenating a range of river types and associated valley bottom systems. The project completed at Hartsop Hall, over 2.1km, saw the wetted channel area increase from 1850m2 to 23,300m2. At Goldrill Beck the project, over 1.6km, saw the wetted channel area increase by 21,590m2. Hydrological data shows that the impact on flood flows has been a mean event lag time increase of 41.3 minutes, with some events having an event lag time increase of 90 minutes. Coarse sediment is also now being stored across the valley bottom with repeat survey showing that more than 2000 m3 of sediment has been stored on one site. The original species-poor assemblage of rush pasture and semi-improved grassland has been disturbed and the vegetation has begun to diversify. The newly formed gravel bars are hosting the greatest diversity of plants, as species that are suited to disturbance and early colonisation are taking advantage. Species such as Corn Spurrey, Bottle Sedge, Fox Glove, and Devils Bit Scabious are increasing in prevalence across the sites, with the partnership now pursuing an expansion of Devils Bit Scabious habitat across the valley prior to a Marsh Fritillary Butterfly re-introduction. Several bird and butterfly species have been recorded on the river restoration sites for the first time, including Jack Snipe, Great White Egret and Small Pearl Bordered Fritillary Butterfly.
Lessons learnt
The biggest success has been the meaningful partnership developed with all landowners and farmers who have worked with us over the past 10 years. A relationship of trust and respect has been built through collaboration, ensuring they are treated as a true partner, can input into design, oversee construction, and take ownership of the results. The momentum of project delivery is increasing, and this can be attributed to the commitment to building and maintaining these relationships.
Funding for projects such as this can be incredibly hard to come by and the partnerships commitment to showcasing our work and communicating passionately about our objectives has resulted in significant income through private donations and crowd funders. A community far wider than Ullswater feel invested in our work.
The partnership has also worked hard to improve local skills and education opportunities. Through the Riverlands project we have hosted 3 apprentices over the last 6 years, galvanising a new generation of river champions. We have worked with local contractors for all projects, providing a learning space for local construction companies to diversify into natural flood management and habitat works. The volume of work has supported numerous small contractors who are now as much a partner to the project as anyone. They have developed a deep understanding of how important it is to protect this landscape and the methods they can use to enhance it.
Image gallery
|
Catchment and subcatchment
Site
Project background
Cost for project phases
Reasons for river restoration
Measures
MonitoringHydromorphological quality elements
Biological quality elements
Physico-chemical quality elements
Any other monitoring, e.g. social, economic
Monitoring documents
Additional documents and videos
Additional links and references
Supplementary InformationEdit Supplementary Information
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||